The Greatest Installment in the Franchise So Far

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 marks a significant evolution in Sega’s iconic speedster’s live-action presence on the silver screen. This film, the latest in the series, breaks away from the typical “family movie” mold, striving to be more faithful to the anime-inspired flair that has characterized the Sonic games for decades. It’s an adaptation that may take creative liberties, but it captures the otherworldly drama that set Sonic apart from similar franchises in the early 2000s. While Sonic 3 does sometimes dip into easy jokes or cringe-worthy scenes, it also embraces the over-the-top action and beloved characters that fans cherish.

One of the biggest strengths of Sonic 3 is how it centers on its non-human characters, correcting the misstep of focusing too much on humans like in the Knuckles spin-off. Here, Sonic and his anthropomorphic companions are given the spotlight. Keanu Reeves shines as Shadow, whose story is one of grief and vengeance, paralleling elements from the games despite some changes. Although Reeves’ performance in the Shadow Generations DLC wasn’t stellar, he brings an emotional depth to the character in the film.

Drawing inspiration from Sonic Adventure 2, Sonic 3 showcases the distinct perspectives of its characters. The movie’s structure mirrors the game’s narrative, oscillating between lighthearted and introspective scenes depending on whether Sonic or Shadow is in focus. While Sonic’s segments are filled with optimism, Shadow brings intensity and reflection, resulting in a poignant exploration of loss through both characters’ eyes.

This duality is expertly crafted, making Sonic 3 a more deliberate video game adaptation. It actively channels the essence of Sonic Adventure 2, although fans might miss Rouge the Bat’s absence. Despite this, the film meticulously highlights the contrasting yet equally compelling skills of Sonic and Shadow. Gone are some of the previous films’ cheesy distractions, like Sonic 2’s bizarre wedding scene or its overused pop culture jokes. Instead, Sonic 3 aims to honor its source material, treating its audience and characters with respect.

Unexpectedly, Jim Carrey’s portrayal of Doctor Robotnik left a sour note. Carrey reprises his role as the mad scientist and also plays Eggman’s grandfather, Gerald Robotnik. Historically a significant yet morbid figure, Gerald’s live presence in Sonic 3 allows for humorous exchanges, although at times these undercut the integrity of the narrative. The film’s reliance on exaggerated antics during Robotnik’s scenes feels more like filler than meaningful content, squandering both Carrey’s talent and the potential of his character.

A recurring issue in the Sonic films has been the emphasis on human characters, often at the expense of the more intriguing storyline featuring Sonic and his friends. Krysten Ritter’s character, GUN agent Director Rockwell, is yet another example of a character who seems unnecessary. Even Idris Elba’s Knuckles suffered in comparison to Carrey’s previously captivating Eggman. Yet now, these movies shine in their focus on Sonic and Shadow’s dynamic, away from the human-centric detours of the past.

The relationships that bring depth to Sonic 3 involve other key characters. Alyla Browne’s portrayal as Shadow’s confidant Maria and Sonic’s bond with James Marsden’s character, Tom, offer heartfelt moments that ground the film. Meanwhile, Agent Stone’s journey with Eggman reveals nuances often missing in such films. Despite these strengths, a lot of comedic responsibility falls on Carrey, resulting in moments that feel forced rather than witty or clever.

Taking liberties with the original game’s plot, Sonic 3 makes changes that are striking even to casual fans, yet it retains the nostalgic angst and style Sonic fans love. It delivers entertainment while paying homage to its roots, celebrating the high-energy clashes between Sonic and Shadow with palpable excitement. This film’s climax is an emotional high point, rewarding viewers for following this journey across three promising movies and a lackluster TV show.

Reflecting on Sonic 3, the word that comes to mind is “earned.” The evolution of these movies since the initial teaser of Ugly Sonic has been remarkable. They’ve brought the charm and authenticity of the Sonic series to a wider audience, retaining the quirky elements that make these characters so beloved. If you’d told me two decades ago that such a faithful live-action version of Sonic Adventure 2 would exist, let alone be this good, I would have been incredulous.